Robinsons
2005-09-18 09:45:09 UTC
Forced Migration May Ultimately Help The Poor
Posted by: Chris Steins
Thanks to: Margy Waller (Brookings Institution)
13 September, 2005 - 9:00am
(Planetizen.com - The internet resource for
professional architects and urban planners)
Mark Alan Hughes predicts some of NOLA's poor
will be better off in a couple years
as a result of forced relocation
to more prosperous places.
Hughes points out that Katrina exposed many things:
the bleak prospects for poor residents in New Orleans,
"our appalling unpreparedness for catastrophic
consequences four years after 9/11, George W. Bush's
callous disregard for the government he heads and the
breadth of support in this country for
government that matters."
Yet, Katrina may prove to be a promising new beginning for some
of poor residents forced to evacuate. At least for those people
fortunate enough to be sheltered in a place that is growing,
not declining.
"Older American cities...have become warehouses
for people whose prospects would be brighter in
other places. But immediate obligations, lack of
resources and information, and plain old inertia
anchor people in places that are declining.
Katrina relocated people in the harshest possible
way, possibly killing thousands and driving
hundreds of thousands away with little or nothing.
If I had the budget, I'd track...poor and near-poor
people who've found refuge in economically
healthier places....I bet that two or three years from
now, most of those folks will be earning more
money in better jobs with their kids attending better
schools in safer neighborhoods....
The lesson of the Mayflower, the frontier, the
Dust Bowl and probably Katrina is that the
eventual happy ending for poor people comes from
relocation more than rebuilding."
Source: Philadelphia Daily News, Sep 13, 2005
Full Story: EVEN A KATRINA CAN BLOW SOME GOOD
http://www.philly.com/mld/dailynews/news/opinion/12630505.htm
Lucky Ducks!!!!
----------
Should The New New Orleans Be Downsized?
15 September, 2005 - 1:00pm
Wall Street Journal
Economists debate whether the future New Orleans
be downsized? 'Colonial Williamsburg' and other
controversial models are pondered.
--------------
Katrina's Silver Lining
Posted by: Abhijeet Chavan
9 September, 2005 - 8:00am
David Brooks argues that Hurricane Katrina has
created an opportunity to address urban poverty.
"Hurricane Katrina has given us an amazing chance
to do something serious about urban poverty.
[It has] given us a chance to rebuild a
city that wasn't working...
"For New Orleans, the key will be luring middle-class
families into the rebuilt city, making it so attractive
to them that they will move in, even knowing that their
blocks will include a certain number of poor people."
Source: New York Times, Sep 08, 2005
-----------------------
"Many experts also warned against moving too
quickly, arguing that being away from the city
could help residents clarify what was most valued
and should be reclaimed. "
-----------------------
Source: New York Times, Sep 14, 2005
Such as... hmm... their schools?
Nah. CLOSED for 9 months!!!!!!!
Tough luck Public School Proles!
Clear your minds in that country air!
"Government that matters" indeed. All we hunger for
is a government that will protect us when the LOOTers
come callin'. It's for their own good not to congregate
in numbers, they need to associate with people who have
"a culture that values work"!! that's why moving to Arkansas
makes it all worthwhile to see ones entire family drown
(according to the Washington Post).
--Brian R.
Posted by: Chris Steins
Thanks to: Margy Waller (Brookings Institution)
13 September, 2005 - 9:00am
(Planetizen.com - The internet resource for
professional architects and urban planners)
Mark Alan Hughes predicts some of NOLA's poor
will be better off in a couple years
as a result of forced relocation
to more prosperous places.
Hughes points out that Katrina exposed many things:
the bleak prospects for poor residents in New Orleans,
"our appalling unpreparedness for catastrophic
consequences four years after 9/11, George W. Bush's
callous disregard for the government he heads and the
breadth of support in this country for
government that matters."
Yet, Katrina may prove to be a promising new beginning for some
of poor residents forced to evacuate. At least for those people
fortunate enough to be sheltered in a place that is growing,
not declining.
"Older American cities...have become warehouses
for people whose prospects would be brighter in
other places. But immediate obligations, lack of
resources and information, and plain old inertia
anchor people in places that are declining.
Katrina relocated people in the harshest possible
way, possibly killing thousands and driving
hundreds of thousands away with little or nothing.
If I had the budget, I'd track...poor and near-poor
people who've found refuge in economically
healthier places....I bet that two or three years from
now, most of those folks will be earning more
money in better jobs with their kids attending better
schools in safer neighborhoods....
The lesson of the Mayflower, the frontier, the
Dust Bowl and probably Katrina is that the
eventual happy ending for poor people comes from
relocation more than rebuilding."
Source: Philadelphia Daily News, Sep 13, 2005
Full Story: EVEN A KATRINA CAN BLOW SOME GOOD
http://www.philly.com/mld/dailynews/news/opinion/12630505.htm
Lucky Ducks!!!!
----------
Should The New New Orleans Be Downsized?
15 September, 2005 - 1:00pm
Wall Street Journal
Economists debate whether the future New Orleans
be downsized? 'Colonial Williamsburg' and other
controversial models are pondered.
--------------
Katrina's Silver Lining
Posted by: Abhijeet Chavan
9 September, 2005 - 8:00am
David Brooks argues that Hurricane Katrina has
created an opportunity to address urban poverty.
"Hurricane Katrina has given us an amazing chance
to do something serious about urban poverty.
[It has] given us a chance to rebuild a
city that wasn't working...
"For New Orleans, the key will be luring middle-class
families into the rebuilt city, making it so attractive
to them that they will move in, even knowing that their
blocks will include a certain number of poor people."
Source: New York Times, Sep 08, 2005
-----------------------
"Many experts also warned against moving too
quickly, arguing that being away from the city
could help residents clarify what was most valued
and should be reclaimed. "
-----------------------
Source: New York Times, Sep 14, 2005
Such as... hmm... their schools?
Nah. CLOSED for 9 months!!!!!!!
Tough luck Public School Proles!
Clear your minds in that country air!
"Government that matters" indeed. All we hunger for
is a government that will protect us when the LOOTers
come callin'. It's for their own good not to congregate
in numbers, they need to associate with people who have
"a culture that values work"!! that's why moving to Arkansas
makes it all worthwhile to see ones entire family drown
(according to the Washington Post).
--Brian R.